Rod Velez won’t be charged, as Broward School Board seat remains in limbo

Rod Velez won’t face any criminal charge for filing to run for the Broward School Board, despite not having his full rights restored from a felony conviction, the State Attorney’s Office has determined.

But prosecutors also say he’s currently ineligible to hold the School Board seat, casting doubts on whether Velez can actually be sworn in. But they also determined he didn’t willfully try to skirt the state law, blaming it on confusion surrounding an amendment that allowed felons to get their voting rights restored.

Advertisement

The issue could be settled as soon as Wednesday afternoon when Circuit Judge Fabienne Fahnestock holds a hearing in a civil case challenging his eligibility. That suit was filed by Marie Murray Martin, the opponent Velez defeated on Nov. 8.

Regardless of the outcome, there’s no avenue for Martin to claim the seat unless she were to be appointed by Gov. Ron DeSantis, legal experts say.

Advertisement

Velez, 52, chose not to be sworn in on Nov. 22 due to legal questions related to his 1995 felony conviction for aggravated battery. His voting rights were restored through Amendment 4, a 2018 ballot initiative passed by Florida voters. But the amendment doesn’t say other rights will be restored, including holding public office and serving on a jury. That requires approval from a state Clemency Board, prosecutors said.

“It is undisputed that without clemency Velez did not meet the qualifications and was not eligible to sign the oath which states, ‘I am qualified under the Constitution and Florida laws to hold the office which I desire to be nominated or elected,’” a closeout memo from the State Attorney’s Office said.

Martin said she agreed with that conclusion.

Rod Velez was elected to the Broward School Board but not sworn in.

“I did my best to notify voters during the end of the general election when Velez admitted he did not have clemency,” Martin told the South Florida Sun Sentinel. “One of my posts on social media stated, ‘a vote for Velez is a vote to allow the Governor to appoint.’”

State law makes it a felony if someone “willfully swears or affirms falsely to any oath or affirmation.”

However, prosecutors and agents determined that Velez did not intentionally make a false statement, due to confusion over which rights are restored to felons.

Velez cited a March 10, 2021, NPR article, titled “Ex-Felons in Florida Gain Right to Serve on Juries and Run for Public Office.” The article quoted DeSantis from a Board of Clemency meeting saying, “I believe that those who have had their voting rights restored under Amendment 4 — it makes sense to also restore the other civil rights.”

But a rule adopted by the Board of Clemency at that meeting actually said that the right to hold public office required a separate application process.

Advertisement

Velez applied for clemency in 2016, but was unsuccessful due to failing to provide the proper documentation, the memo said. He applied again in September, after he had already advanced to a runoff, but the state has so far taken no action on his application.

“The 2018 change in the law was confusing even for seasoned attorneys and investigators and as such would be confusing for the general public,” the State Attorney’s Office wrote.

Velez’s lawyer, Michael Gottlieb, told the Sun Sentinel he applauds the State Attorney’s decision, but disagrees with its conclusion that Velez is ineligible to hold office without clemency.

“There’s a long body of case law that suggests your right to vote also gives you the right to hold office,” said Gottlieb, who is also a state representative from Davie. He said the cases date to when Blacks and women were granted the right to vote.

Velez will have to decide soon whether to take an oath to be sworn into office. State statute says that someone who is elected or appointed to a public office has 30 days to qualify or the seat becomes vacant. Thursday is the 30-day mark.

Some lawyers say if the seat is still vacant after then, DeSantis would appoint a replacement. Others say the seat would automatically revert to Ryan Reiter, a DeSantis appointee who was the last School Board member to occupy the seat.