U.S. bans shark fin trade in effort to curb inhumane practice of ‘finning’

President Biden has signed a bill that bans the buying and selling of shark fins in the U.S. The law is meant to combat the practice of shark “finning.”

Shark finning typically occurs when commercial fishermen on the high seas cut a shark’s fins off for sale to the lucrative market in Asia, where the fins are used in soup. The sharks are then dumped overboard alive, where they flounder to their deaths.

Advertisement

The law is part of the James M. Inhofe National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2023.

Though Asia is the epicenter of the shark fin market, fins can be legally harvested by commercial fishermen in the U.S. if fishermen bring the fish to land whole. Under the new law, they will have to discard fins, which can represent 25% of the shark’s economic value.

Advertisement

The practice of shark finning was made illegal in the U.S. in 2000, but foreign-sourced fins still pass through the country. In 2020, the Washington Post reported that a U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service investigation resulted in the indictment of a wildlife trafficking ring that allegedly smuggled more than 12,000 pounds of dried shark fins from Mexico into the U.S. and shipped them to Hong Kong via a Florida-based front company.

Cat Uden, South Florida field representative for Oceana, one of the groups behind the bill, said the law is important because differentiating between legal and illegal fins was quite difficult.

“Other countries don’t have the protections the U.S. does, and fish in a very inhumane and unsustainable way,” Uden said. “The U.S. was essentially involved in that fin trade practice, so we were contributing to the problem. A federal ban improves enforcement of the current finning ban, and would reinforce the status of the United States as a leader in shark conservation.”

Opponents say the law harms a well-regulated and sustainable U.S. shark fishery, where finning does not occur. Commercial fishermen in the U.S. who legally land sharks will be forced to throw away valuable fins. “By making fishermen throw the fins in the dumpster, you’re taking away 25% of their income,” said Robert Hueter, scientist emeritus at Mote Marine Laboratory and chief scientist at Ocearch, a shark research nonprofit that studies white sharks.

Uden, of Oceana, said, “[Our] position has always been that if you’re not solely fishing for fins, and you have a legitimate fishery, then taking the fins out of the fishery is not going to put you out of business.”

“The banning of the fin industry is a symbolic move that is based on an emotional response to seeing animals that have had their fins cut off at sea and are dumped,” Hueter said. “This is all being done by foreign fleets, in countries where they have illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing going on, and that’s not happening in the United States.”

Hueter fears that ending the U.S. fin fishery may make things worse. “It’s counterproductive because it removes the model of a sustainable correctly managed fishery and a full-utilization fishery off the table. … It rewards market share to those who are doing it wrong.”

According to Oceana, millions of sharks end up in fin trade every year — some finned illegally, some harvested legally, while one-third of the shark species in the Hong Hong fin trade are threatened with extinction.

Advertisement

A study published in the journal Nature in 2021 suggests that “since 1970, the global abundance of oceanic sharks and rays has declined by 71% owing to an 18-fold increase in relative fishing pressure.”

Hueter acknowledges that finning is a terrible problem, and that global shark populations have been severely reduced. In U.S. waters, though, he sees pronounced improvement.

“The shark fisheries we have now are largely sustainable. Many of these shark species have recovered after the depletions that occurred after the 1960s through the 1980s. The United States is identified as what’s called a bright spot of sustainable shark fishing in the world, both commercially and recreationally.”

For U.S. fishermen, sandbar sharks and blacktip sharks are the primary commercial species, and their fins vary in quality. Blacktips fins are not considered grade-A, but still have value, Heuter said. Sandbar sharks have very high-grade fins and are valuable. They comprise quite a bit of the income for those who fish for them.

A 7-foot sandbar shark alongside a recreational sport fishing charter boat a few miles off the Miami Beach on July 14, 2017. The vessel is not involved in commercial shark harvest. (Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)

Hueter said that hammerhead sharks have some of the most coveted fins, but are a protected species and must always be released.

“The catch of sandbar sharks is still greatly limited,” Hueter said. “The blacktip shark is totally rebuilt, and is actually in very good shape in the Atlantic and the Gulf of Mexico.”

Advertisement

One exception to the law: The possession of fins from the smooth dogfish and spiny dogfish would be allowed. Their fins are smaller and less valuable.

Most commercial shark fishing is done with longline gear, where thousands of hooks are set out along a main line that can stretch several miles.

This can result in any species being caught, but Hueter said U.S. commercial fishermen “are not interested in catching things they can’t keep. We have about 20 or so prohibited species that have to be released. [The commercial fleet] is really good at targeting areas and times of year where they’re going to get primarily the target species,” he said.

Some shark species survive release from longline capture better than others. A 2021 study led by the New England Aquarium and co-authored by Hueter found that sandbar, tiger, and bull sharks had better survival rates than blacktip and spinner sharks.

Finning is also illegal in the European Union, but an International Fund for Animal Welfare analysis of market data from 2003 to 2020 found that EU nations, particularly Spain, Portugal, the Netherlands, France and Italy, lead the way in legal harvest of whole sharks in which fins are sold to the Asian market.

According to National Geographic, shark fin soup consumption in China has dropped by about 80% since 2011. It’s now illegal to serve the delicacy at government banquets, and celebrity-backed awareness campaigns have likely had an impact. NBA star Yao Ming participated in a campaign with the slogan “when the buying stops, the killing can too.”